Monday, July 28, 2008

Oil price drop too little and too late

Oil prices dropped 15% in just 10 days. However, it is too little and too late to slow inflationary pressures much

breakingviews.com | Edward Hadas


A barrel of oil cost less than $124 (about Rs5,230) on Thursday, a 15% fall in just 10 days. For those worrying about rising prices, the declining trend is welcome, despite Thursday’s tiny bounce. But it is too little and too late to slow inflationary pressures much.

ure, upward pressure on petrol prices should ease within days or weeks. But they will still be high. After all, the crude oil price has only dropped back to where it was two months ago—when it seemed almost unbearably expensive—and is still roughly 70% more costly than a year ago.


Also, while oil prices are softening, other energy-related prices are rising. Natural gas contracts mostly follow the oil market, but usually with a six-month lag. Electricity price hikes are even slower, as they mostly require regulatory approval. And consumers will eventually pay for more expensive oil in everything from plastic packaging to imported Christmas tree ornaments, but it can take a year or more.

Also, while oil prices are softening, other energy-related prices are rising. Natural gas contracts mostly follow the oil market, but usually with a six-month lag. Electricity price hikes are even slower, as they mostly require regulatory approval. And consumers will eventually pay for more expensive oil in everything from plastic packaging to imported Christmas tree ornaments, but it can take a year or more.

This gradual effect can be seen as a simple process of inventories working through the system. But there may also be a subtler monetary undercurrent, as economists Frank Browne and David Cronin of the Central Bank and Financial Services Authority of Ireland have argued.

When money supply expands, customers bid up prices across the board. Historically, commodity prices have been the first to rise, because they are the most flexible. But the two economists suggest that other prices have followed, even when commodity prices fall back. Eventually, everything ends up costing about the same proportion more than before the money supply increased.

One price is particularly important for future inflation—the price of labour. If workers can negotiate pay hikes that keep up with the cost of living, they will keep the inflationary ball rolling. It looks like employees will be able to collect lots of evidence over the next few months to support their case.

No ceasefire on inflation, rates should go up

RBI should wait and watch the trajectory of inflation as well as the monsoon before taking a call on further rate hikes

Banker’s Trust | Tamal Bandyopadhyay


Will Reserve Bank of India, or RBI, governor Yaga Venugopal Reddy call a truce in his war on inflation when he unveils the quarterly monetary policy review on 29 July, and leave interest rates unchanged? Or, will he continue to tighten policy by raising interest rates and soaking up liquidity through an increase in commercial banks’ cash reserve ratio, or CRR, in the belief that the beast of inflation is yet to be caged?

The market is divided on the stance of the July review, the last in the Reddy regime. Those bankers and bond dealers who strongly feel that the time is ripe to rein in Reddy’s aggression in raising rates, cite three developments to build their argument. First, the drop in the wholesale price-based inflation from 11.91% to 11.89% for the week ended 12 July, the first such drop in two months. Second, a decline in industrial production. The year-on-year growth rate in industrial production in May fell to 3.8%, its lowest in six years. Finally, they point to a drop in crude oil prices.

Since the beginning of the current fiscal, Reddy has raised the policy rate by 75 basis points to 8.5% and CRR by 125 basis points to 8.75%. One basis point is one-hundredth of a percentage point. These bankers and bond dealers feel any policy action at this juncture is not necessary and RBI should wait and watch the trajectory of inflation as well as the monsoon before taking a call on further rate hikes.

But there are others who equally strongly feel that it’s too early to wave the white flag and RBI should continue what it has been doing—making money dearer by raising policy rates. I would go with this group. Inflation is a bigger enemy than the slowdown and there is no room for complacency. At 11.89%, inflation is still more than double of what the central bank is comfortable with. More importantly, a drop of 2 basis points does not mean that inflation has reached its peak, particularly when the base effects will continue to remain unfavourable for the next few months. It had fallen from 4.7% to 3.1% between July and October last year and, because of the lower base, inflation will continue to remain in double digits for quite sometime and may not come down before the year-end. An uneven monsoon can queer the pitch further as it will impact food prices. So far, 14 out of 36 meteorological sub-divisions across India have received either deficient or scanty rainfall, the worst distribution of rain in four years.

Indeed, supply constraints are contributing to the rising inflation. But there are demand pressures too. There is no drop in investment demand as well as demand for consumer durables. Besides, non-oil imports are rising at a considerable pace.

The year-on-year growth in money supply has marginally come down to 20.5%, from 21.8% last year, but it is still well above the RBI projection of 16.5-17% for 2009. Similarly, aggregate deposits in the banking system have grown by 21.7% this year against RBI projection of 17% and credit growth has been 25.7%, substantially higher than RBI’s target of 20%. All these indicate growth impulses and monetary policy, the proverbial first line of defence against inflation, should come to the fore by raising the policy rate by 25 basis points or so.

There may not be any need to raise CRR at this point, as liquidity is already tight. Banks, on an average, borrowed around Rs45,000 crore daily from RBI last week and the rates in the overnight call money market, from where banks borrow to tide over their temporary asset-liability mismatches, have been hovering around 9%, above RBI’s policy rate.

Death of bank rate?

Is the bank rate, RBI’s most potent signalling device, dead? The last time this rate was tinkered with was in April 2003, when it was brought down by 25 basis points to a three-decade low of 6%. Since then, there has been no change in the rate even though the reverse repo rate has gone up from 4.5% to 6%, and the repo rate from 6% to 8.5%. The reverse repo rate is the rate at which banks park their short-term excess liquidity with RBI and the central bank pumps in short-term liquidity into the system at the repo rate.

Earlier, the bank rate was the refinance rate at which banks used to draw down liquidity support from RBI. But this has now been delinked from the refinance rate. The bank rate is a statement of RBI’s views on interest rates in the medium term, while repo rate is a short-term signalling device. But how “medium” is the medium-term view?

One can always argue that there are too many policy rates and why add another, especially one that has not been changed in a long time. But then, the bank rate is a signal of where medium-term interest rates should be and, by implication, where medium-term inflation is likely to settle. In an environment where managing inflationary expectations is the central bank’s most important job, wouldn’t it be wise to increase the bank rate?

The real policy rate is now at -339 basis points (inflation at 11.89% and repo rate 8.5). Since double-digit inflation is here to stay for at least a few more months, isn’t it better to give a medium-term signal to the market and be perceived as being ahead of the curve? In spite of the 125 basis points increase in CRR and 75 basis points rise in the repo rate, the corresponding hikes in banks’ lending rates are far lower. An increase in the bank rate will encourage banks to raise their lending rates and make money costlier.

Economists betting on hike in bank rate and cash reserve ratio

Many analysts say that despite the recent fall in crude prices, high inflation is here to stay, at least for a while

Anup Roy


Mumbai: On the sidelines of a 23 June event in Pune, Reserve Bank of India governor Yaga Venugopal Reddy conceded that “there is a legitimate concern about the recent developments on the inflation front”.

He then called upon all market participants, in particular the financial market participants, “to appreciate the problem with the analysis at their command, participate with us in managing demand and maintaining orderly conditions in financial markets, while drawing upon the strengths of their respective balance sheets.”

(REDDY RECKONER) This is possibly the strongest statement Reddy has ever made since his tenure began in September 2003.

On the same day, Reddy went on to say: “The RBI will continue to take determined and calibrated measures, as and when warranted, with a focus on managing expectations and on enabling adjustments in the economy in response to the oil shock.

Indeed, the very next day, RBI announced a hike in the short-term policy rate, or so-called repo rate, by half a percentage point to 8.5%. The banking regulator also raised banks’ cash reserve ratio, or CRR, the cash that they are required to keep with the central bank, by an identical margin to 8.75%.

RBI also promised to resort to “both conventional and unconventional measures” to manage “inflation expectations, financial stability and growth momentum.”

(MINT SNAP POLL ON MONETARY POLICY) All this then brings us to what might have changed in this scenario during the past four weeks.

For one, India’s wholesale price-based inflation reached 11.05%, up from 4.28% a year ago. Since then, inflation has gone up to 11.89%. Still, the price of crude, the main trigger for the rising inflation, has dropped from $147(Rs6,200 today) a barrel to $124 a barrel.

But, apart from a drop in oil prices, there has not been any change in all macro-economic developments in the past one month. The banking industry’s credit as well as deposit growth have been higher than what RBI had projected in its annual monetary policy announced in April. So has been the growth in money supply and reserve money.

And many economists say, despite a fall in crude oil prices, high inflation is here to stay for a while. “Inflationary concerns will continue in India for another six months,” predicts Rupa Rege Nitsure, chief economist of the public sector Bank of Baroda.

According to Nitsure, just as the rise in crude prices was not fully passed on to the customers, the fall in crude prices also will not be felt by the masses.

“Under-recovery of oil marketing companies are almost 2.5% of GDP (gross domestic products). Only 25-30% of the increase in the crude oil prices has been passed on to the masses,” Nitsure said.

According to her, the bad monsoon this year, the worst for the last five years, has also spelt bad news as far as the sowing of kharif crops is concerned. The monsoon in July year was 2% below its long period average.

“All major commodities are under strain. Post monsoon there is always an increase in cement prices. And, steel price control will also ease from October. The governor has been saying that inflation will remain in double digits. Socially, it is an unacceptable level,” she added.

A recent Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd research report also said the oil prices and monsoon will determine the inflation views. Kotak Mahindra Bank estimates that inflation could touch 14% by end December before it starts falling.

“International crude oil prices and the south-west monsoon (June-September) are two of the most important factors for inflation at the moment,” it said.

“We believe that RBI will act aggressively in the coming months to reign in inflationary expectations, even as inflation appears to have stabilized for the moment. We expect RBI to hike the repo rate by 25 basis points on 29 July credit policy and possibly another 50 basis points before March 09,” Kotak Mahindra Bank economists Indranil Pan and Kaushik Das said in their research report, dated 25 July.

Both Nitsure and Kotak Mahindra Bank’s economists say that CRR will be the preferred tool when liquidity improves, and could be exercised during inter-meeting dates.

A recent Lehman Brothers report, by its India economist Sonal Verma, also said the inflation rate is “unlikely to reach the RBI’s 5.5% target anytime during fiscal 2009” and “it will be interesting to see whether RBI officially changes its inflation target or just highlights the serious risk of its target being overshot.”

Lehman Brothers is expecting a 25 basis points hike in repo rate and a “50:50 chance” a 25-50 basis points hike in CRR.

ICICI Bank Ltd’s research division also expects a repo rate hike but no change in CRR. However, it does not rule out any post-policy measures if the “inflation scenario were to worsen significantly”.

Indeed, the industrial production growth has come down but analysts are not giving too much importance to that at this point.

“Our analysis suggests that the central bank pays little attention to industrial developments when determining rates,” HSBC economist Robert Prior-Wandesforde said in a research report. “While acknowledging the RBI often likes to surprise markets, we are sticking with our call of 25 basis points repo and CRR hikes at next Tuesday’s meeting and a total of 100 basis points of increases in both rates between now and the end of calendar 2008.”

Abheek Barua, chief economist of HDFC Bank Ltd, said the industrial production rate has fallen due to some adverse base affect of the year. “Inflation is going to be a priority now for the central bank rather than the growth. Hence, RBI would want to rein in inflation by hiking CRR. Any explicit rate signal will be given after this policy,” Baruah said.

Abheek Barua, chief economist of HDFC Bank Ltd, said the industrial production rate has fallen due to some adverse base affect of the year. “Inflation is going to be a priority now for the central bank rather than the growth. Hence, RBI would want to rein in inflation by hiking CRR. Any explicit rate signal will be given after this policy,” Baruah said.

Monday, July 21, 2008

Govt talking to steel makers to control prices: FM

Steel prices have since January shot up by about 50%, triggering concerns soaring rates were fuelling inflation


PTI

New Delhi: Amid reports that leading steel producers may raise prices from the first week of August, Finance Minister P Chidambaram has said the government is in dialogue with the manufacturers to keep the rates under check.

“All I know is that the Ministry of Steel is talking to steel producers to persuade them to keep prices under check,” Chidambaram told PTI in an interaction.

Asked if government may take fiscal measures to ensure steel prices don’t spiral after expiry of the three-month self-moratorium imposed by primary producers on their price line, the Finance Minister said: “I can’t talk about fiscal measures. I know that there is a dialogue between steel ministry and steel producers.”

In view of the apprehensions regarding price rise of steel items, the Committee of Secretaries (CoS) recently decided that the Ministry of Steel in consultation with Department of Revenue would soon consider suitable measures for increasing domestic availability of steel and moderating its prices.

Among others, the ensuing CoS meeting is likely to consider an increase in export duty on flat and long steel products besides upward duty revision on export of iron ore.

At present, flat steel products are exempted from export duty while long steel items attract 15%. Overseas iron ore shipments attract 15% ad-valorem duty.

Steel prices have since January shot up by about 50%, triggering concerns that soaring rates of the alloy were augmenting inflationary pressures on the economy.

Beyond today’s politics

If public policy is for the few and by the few, it would only alienate the citizenry, sooner rather than later


Policy Track | S. Narayan


I can well imagine how excitement and expectations today would overshadow concerns about economic issues, but the real world of goods and services, of markets and trade, will go on independent of the blips of politics. The last couple of weeks have been particularly interesting, and a lesson on how differently similar problems are being handled in the US, UK and here.


The concerns over the likely implosion of the two massive mortgage security institutions in the US—Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac—are an example. These are government-supported institutions (GSEs), which buy mortgages from banks using debt raised in the market at lower interest rates. Once the underlying mortgages get distressed, so does the business model. These two institutions account for a significant proportion of the mortgage debt outstanding in the US, and a collapse would ripple through the entire financial market. In the wake of the likely implosion of a California-based bank, the Fed and the treasury have moved swiftly to find a solution. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac will have access to federal funds in the form of debt, equity and guarantees, but existing shareholders would have to take the brunt of lower values. There have been academic debates on two counts—first, concern over state intervention in a country where markets are traditionally left to determine winners and losers; and second, the moral hazard of choosing new equity over the older shareholders, arguing that this would reduce future risk taking by investors. But markets and the public have broadly welcomed the moves.

Note that in an unusual situation, the treasury and the Fed have not been averse to finding new solutions, in fact pragmatic ones over theoretical, and the treasury secretary is winning applause as a problem solver. At the same time, the Fed chairman is open about his concerns and has presented a grim picture of inflation and economic slowdown.

So, pragmatism and transparency, and an attempt to ensure swift action to protect the masses of investors and customers. In short, less economists, more doers.

Similarly, in the UK, there is transparency over the Bank of England’s letters to the chancellor saying that they would have to live with the inflationary pressures, as any monetary tightening would slow growth further. There is also the promise that banks and institutions in distress would be supported.

Let’s compare this with events here. First, there is an assertion in the media, and in public, by policymakers, ministers, etc., that there is nothing to worry about. It has been said that inflation will decline by itself; the economy would continue to grow; food prices would be higher; and people would have difficulties making ends meet, but everything is fine. And in any case, the problems are due to causes beyond our control and, hence, there is nothing much to do. One has only to watch the TV to see this message repeatedly coming across from the government.

It is possible to argue that in the face of declining growth in industrial production, lower capex investments, and slowing infrastructure development, pragmatic answers are possible. For example, and there could be other ideas as well, focused support to investment and industry as well as emphasis on rapid infrastructure development could ensure that we do not get into a downturn. It is better to react early than too late. Further, if it is clear that higher oil prices are here to stay, is it not important to know the strategies for dealing with the future? In terms of problem solving, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has also been a hesitant conservative. Depreciation of the rupee has certainly added to inflationary pressures, but RBI has not sought to deploy its reserves to stem this, and reduce the burden of the market stabilization scheme bonds.

The other, more significant departure is the concern over individuals, over shareholders, rather than public at large. The windfall tax controversy is a case in point. Windfall gains are associated with lotteries, where a risky investment is made with a low chance of success. How would unexpected increases in oil prices constitute windfall gains? If there have been aberrations in policy, these need to be addressed, and a wakeful media needs to question how these aberrations happened, but to raise this to the level of a national debate is surely a waste of resources in itself.

This brings me to the final thought. Everywhere I have gone, I can actually see the benefits of government activity for citizens. In Cambodia, I recently saw a large public lake being upgraded into a leisure spot, where the buzz among citizens was about the benefit from tourist inflows. Why are there very few public projects in India that people relate to, where they can see direct benefits? The Delhi Metro, of course, is an exception. If public policy is for the few and by the few, it would only alienate the citizenry, sooner rather than later.

Ask Mint | Inflation revisited: causes, effects and a ready reckoner on basic terms and facts

An inflation rate of 10% means that the general level of prices of goods and services has increased by 10%

Real Simple | Shailaja and Manoj K Singh


Whenever we talk about inflation, everything seems to be a repeat of the past. The script has all the obvious elements: price shocks, excess money supply, declining output, monetary tightening, fiscal measures, et al. Grown-ups have seen many such phases of ups and downs. But kids born in the last 10 years are seeing double-digit inflation for the first time in their lives. So let’s put together some of the basic terms associated with inflation that will serve as a ready reference for all time.

Jinny: Wherever I go these days, I see inflation-hit faces. What to say of kids, even some of our older folks are looking utterly confused. Many of them seem to have blissfully forgotten the old lessons.

Johnny: I think, Jinny, it’s the right time to repeat the old lessons. Tell me the most basic thing first: What do we mean by inflation?

Jinny: Inflation is defined as an increase in the general level of prices of goods and services from one period to another (generally one year). It is measured in terms of per cent change in the value of a price index consisting of a basket of goods and services. An inflation rate of 10% means that the general level of prices of goods and services has increased by 10% over the period. In other words, it means that for purchasing the same amount of goods and services, you have to pay 10% more money.

But, you may ask, why do prices increase year after year? Can’t we have constant prices over a period? Or better still, can’t we make prices actually fall from one period to another? Well, the prices of goods and services in a free market are determined by the forces of demand and supply. So you can’t have constant prices unless your demand and supply remain constant. Generally, it is observed that demand increases faster than the supply of goods and services, leading to increases in prices of goods and services over a period.


However, in unusual times, when demand is slacking, you may actually observe a fall in the general level of prices, which in technical terms is called deflation. This is the opposite of inflation.


Is that good for the economy? No. Both high inflation and deflation adversely affect the economy. It is believed that moderate inflation over a period of time is good for the economy because it encourages producers to increase output.

However, an unexpectedly high increase or fall in prices has the opposite effect. High inflation reduces the purchasing power of the money in the hands of people, leading to a decline in aggregate demand in the economy, which compels producers to decrease output.

Falling prices, on the other hand, make production of additional goods non-lucrative and so encourage producers to voluntarily cut their output.

Johnny: So, the problem of inflation is actually a problem of unexpectedly high increases in prices. Now tell me, how is cost-push inflation different from demand-pull inflation?

Jinny: Demand-pull inflation is caused by excess money leading to an increase in aggregate demand in the economy. It is a case of “too much money chasing too few goods”. Aggregate demand includes both consumption and investment.

This kind of inflation is best controlled by monetary measures such as high interest rates and asking banks to maintain high cash reserves, which act as brakes on money supply.

Cost-push inflation, on the other hand, is caused by supply-side constraints. The high cost of labour or raw materials may force producers to increase the prices of their goods and services. High crude oil and food prices are examples of supply shocks leading to unexpected increases in prices of other goods and services. This kind of inflation requires more careful use of monetary and fiscal measures.

Johnny: Economists talk about core and headline inflation. Now what are these?

Jinny: Headline inflation is most commonly represented by a price index consisting of a basket of different goods and services. Core inflation is what we get after removing volatile elements such as oil and food from this basket of goods and services. So, headline inflation is often higher than core inflation.

Johnny: I often hear that inflation hurts the old and the poor the most. How does inflation affect our lives?


Jinny: Well, how inflation is going to affect you depends on where you are placed. People living on fixed incomes, such as retirees, feel the pinch more. Inflation eats away the value of their fixed income day by day.

A person living on borrowed money is probably better off because inflation decreases the real value of the debt if the inflation rate is higher than the interest rate. Today, you can have breakfast and lunch with the borrowed money.

But tomorrow, when you pay back the money, your lender realizes that he can only buy breakfast with the same amount of money. Uncertainty about the future always hurts economic growth.

Johnny: That’s true, Jinny. We need to save our kids from the uncertainty of inflation.

What: Inflation is defined as an increase in the general level of prices of goods and services from one period to another.

How: Demand-pull inflation is caused by increase in aggregate demand in the economy whereas cost-push inflation is caused by supply-side constraints.

Why: High inflation reduces the purchasing power of money, leading to a decrease in aggregate demand, which slows economic growth.

Monday, July 7, 2008

Shoe, ships and sealing wax

The Centre can’t take recourse to the Bhagavad Gita saying it’s only responsible for action by providing funds






In his Budget speech on Friday, the finance minister repeatedly expressed anxiety and a trace of helplessness about the implementation of various projects and schemes. The proposals included the setting up of a national monitoring agency to oversee implementation and additional funding worth Rs10,000 crore as incentive for states that complete projects. The Prime Minister, in a television interview after the Budget, said the Centre could allocate funds, but the onus of implementation was often on states and “one had to work with different state governments of differing capabilities” to make this happen.

Such an approach offers no clue about how implementation is to improve. The Centre can’t take recourse to the Bhagavad Gita and say it is only responsible for action by providing funds, and not for the results thereof. Further, this is a good way to hide the poor performance in infrastructure—the National Highway Development Programme is four years behind schedule, the 11th Plan targets for power generation are already slipping, and there’s little progress in various Centrally funded projects. In contrast, the airport at Beijing, the biggest and the most modern in the world today, was completed in four years.

It is by now clear to all that poor governance delivery will lead inexorably to slowing of the economy and to increase the gaps between the haves and have-nots. In the next few columns, I’d like to focus on how things can perhaps be got done.

I need to assume certain givens. First, at the highest levels in the Union and state governments, there is realization that performance is as important for electoral success as are regional and other political considerations. Second, administrative machin- eries have become complex, slow, and unwilling to move and act—and corruption is growing. Finally, little can be done in the short term to change the mechanisms of delivery, for there is none that can take on the structure.

The most important deliverables are those that affect the poor. They expect two kinds of services. In the rural areas, it is access to fertilizer and seeds and, perhaps, kerosene. (Now there is also employment guarantee, that’s the National Rural Employment Guarantee Programme). In the urban areas, it is foodgrain from the public distribution system (PDS) and fuel—kerosene. The problems are of two types—covering all those eligible, and making the products available. The Budget initiative of using smart cards is a step in the right direction—especially for the urban poor. These would be entitlement cards for specific PDS services. The rent-seeking and corruption arise not from denying those eligible, but in the creation of a number of “bogus” cards, the entitlements for which are sold in the open market. As long as those eligible get the benefits, we should, in the near term, live with these corruption costs, else the system won’t work. The finesse in administration lies in how low one can get these “overheads” without bringing the system to halt—too tight, and it gets strangled; too loose, and there is leakage everywhere.

Having got the cards, the poor need the goods. One system that’s worked very well in this country is milk delivery. When “token”-based milk kiosks were first set up, there were some complaints about adulteration and quantity, but community pressure soon put an end to that. Kerosene can be delivered through similar kiosks, if set up in every petrol retail outlet, or even as a stand-alone in busy residential areas. These could be run by the public sector oil marketing companies. Swipe your card, and get your entitlement. Note that we’re still in urban areas. The other important expectation is foodgrain. In several states, there is subsidized delivery of rice, wheat, sometimes pulses and oil as well. The PDS system is notoriously inefficient. Again, in urban areas, it is possible to use our software skills to ensure delivery. Some costs may be incurred in packaging—this could be outsourced to the private sector, or better still, to women self-help groups. Package with a bar code that the retailer can swipe against the smart card, and hey presto, you have a verifiable system of quantity delivered against each card, total off-take and a host of other data in your server. The costs of setting up the system are well worth it, considering the continuous leakages over the years.

An important point is that these cards don’t need to be anything other than for the specific purpose for now: not citizenship, voter or any other cards. And they would get issued after the current processes of verification are complete.

Handling delivery in rural areas is a bit more complex, as one must factor in the problems of infrastructure logistics, and the lower awareness and literacy levels. There are also more services apart from PDS, there are inputs for agriculture and, finally, credit. In the next column, I would like to deal with these.

(S. Narayan is a former finance secretary and economic adviser to the prime minister. We welcome your comments at policytrack@livemint.com)

Not a rosy picture anymore

Inflation in India is not confined to food and fuel prices



When the Bric report came out a few years ago, there were seminars and rah–rahs everywhere as though 2050 was already here and India, along with Brazil, Russia and China, had already reached superpower status. This report by Goldman Sachs led to such euphoria that companies went about spending lavishly on Davos dinners and announcing the greatness of the Indian economic growth story. Well, the same group has put out a report again last week, clearly pointing out that India has seriously slipped behind the other three countries and revising the expectations of the earlier report.

Jim O’Neill and Tushar Poddar of Goldman Sachs have summarized the 10 important tasks that India needs to carry out to achieve its potential and, by all counts, the list is quite forbidding. It includes improving governance, introducing credible fiscal policy, raising basic educational standards, boosting agricultural productivity and infrastructure. Internally, many investment assessments have already put a question mark on India, and last week’s figures of 11% inflation will only add to the worries. Not surprisingly, those who praised the earlier report as the Word of Truth have little to comment on the new one.

In the UK, the Bank of England is mandated by law to do inflation targeting, and if it fails to keep inflation below 2%, write an open letter to the chancellor of the treasury explaining why it has been unable to do so. The most recent such letter was put in the public domain late last week and makes interesting reading. It points out that there are likely to be several more such letters in the coming months and that inflation in the UK, currently at 4%, is likely to persist until the end of 2009. It states the bank would not be adopting a tighter money policy for the present, for that might contract the economy further, and argues that constituents of the inflationary pressure are limited to oil and food, and that there is little pressure on other goods and services. There is an expectation that the price rises in commodities would ease up and given that there is no wage pressure, the chances are that oil and food pressures would ease in six months or so. Hence, it is inadvisable to use monetary weapons to slow the economy. Buoyed by huge exports of defence equipment, the real economy in the UK is chugging along fairly normally.

In the US, too, the Fed has pointed out that it might like to wait and watch given that tech companies are doing well, and there is a resurgence of exports. The damage, so far, has been confined to housing and related sectors other than the financial markets and, therefore, it’s time to wait and watch on monetary tightening.

The comparison with the situation in India is quite stark. Some months ago, policymakers were confident that the Indian economy was sufficiently decoupled from the US economy to continue to grow. It does appear decoupled, but in a different direction.

Inflation in India is not confined to food and fuel prices. In fact, given good harvests and excellent government stocks, there is an easing of pressure on the food front, except in edible oils. There is genuine pressure on wages and the shortage of skilled labour has pushed up wage costs significantly. The worry is that the middle class is not yet in a panic over the high prices — this clearly indicates that higher wages are in fact a cause of higher prices. This pressure on wages is due to the absence of a policy on the part of the government to improve manpower availability through skill training and put educational institutions in order. This is needed to meet the demands of a fast growing economy.

Surely, no blame can be put on the Left for this — government commissions had pointed to skilled manpower problems even in 2005, but little has been done. Apart from wages, there are genuine cost pushes — in power, transportation and raw material costs that are adding to the pressures. Unlike the US and UK today, there are no sectors that are reporting sterling performance, and this is a cause for worry.

Under the circumstances, the Reserve Bank of India moving towards a tighter money policy will slow growth further. Given this cycle of inflation and credit squeeze, we may see the US and UK snap out of stagflation sooner than our economy.

There have been a lot of opportunities missed by the UPA, which have little to do with opposition from the Left. These include improvement in infrastructure, a focus on agriculture and education, and a focus on power generation to ease energy pressures. Most importantly, there has been a significant failure to address supply-side constraints in a growing economy, whether in commodities, agriculture or manpower. It is going to be difficult for the new government to bring these back on track except with tight financial control and better governance. The next few years for the Indian economy are unlikely to be as rosy as the years before even if growth may continue at around 7%.

S. Narayan is a former finance secretary and economic adviser to the prime minister. We welcome your comments at policytrack@livemint.com

Dismal fiscal situation

Payments for commodities and imports are squeezing liquidity out of the system and the huge increases in government borrowings will make commercial credit dearer and interest rates higher without doing much for inflation


I always thought I would be able to see the bright side of things in economic management, but increasingly my vision is of the dark at the end of the tunnel, thanks to the news that is coming in every day. We are now told that the cost for the farm debt waiver would be much greater than anticipated, and several of my friends in rural areas, who are otherwise not so badly off, have told me that their bank manger had called them and told them that in order to meet his waiver targets, he was reclassifying their jewel loans as agricultural loans and writing them off.

I have gone through the detailed instructions of the finance ministry on this scheme, and am quite convinced that it has large loopholes for even elephants to pass through. I have no problem with direct cash transfers for the poor — in fact, I have been advocating this as a policy to replace all the leaky and corrupt schemes — but it bothers me that we cannot put together a scheme that takes into account the ground-level conditions and ensures that delivery losses are minimized. The loan waiver is likely to turn into a bottomless pit, with claims continuing to come in long after the final date announced by the ministry, and we shall never see the final figures until the comptroller and auditor general brings them up two or three years later.

We are also told that very large sums have now been set apart for the payments under the pay commission awards to government staff. This would be interesting on several counts — first, as the Budget, in an attempt to be clever, made no provisions for these payments, any large sums would need to be voted by Parliament, an iffy proposition in these troubled times. Second, since no one is happy with the recommendations of the commission, there has to be a mechanism to examine these claims and take decisions, a difficult proposition if the government is reduced to a minority. Third, the actual payments would entail substantial increases in borrowings, in the fiscal deficit, in liquidity and, therefore, in inflation. At the same time, if these grants are not made, it is goodbye to the votes of the government staff, especially the uniformed personnel. It’s easy to understand the dilemma of the government, and also easy not to sympathize with it, for it had it coming for over a year, with the writing on the wall very clear on inflation and liquidity.

Finally, I cannot understand the need for self-flagellation in putting out inflation numbers every Friday — numbers that the ministry admits are incorrect and not based on adequate reports. It should be very easy for the government to say that it’s looking at the statistical base for these numbers, and they would be put out once a month. I have not come across any other country that whips itself every Friday.

Even at this time, there are options available to the government to get things back on the rails. As the rupee weakens against a weakening dollar, we are importing inflation hand over fist. Oil at $146 will be costlier if the rupee has also fallen during this time. Payments for commodities and imports are squeezing liquidity out of the system and the huge increases in government borrowings will make commercial credit dearer and interest rates higher without doing much for inflation. As a columnist wrote, cash reserve ratio and repo rates of more than 8% while inflation is at 11% still mean a negative interest rate, and will have little effect on inflationary pressures. It might make more sense to go for a strong rupee with the Reserve Bank selling dollars to let the rupee appreciate. The additional liquidity could easily be absorbed by government and by the industrial sector.

At the same time, it is necessary to get confidence back into industry and services to provide for growth and export opportunities so that the economy can continue to grow. Investments in power and other infrastructure are an obvious choice, as also the quick approvals for mining and extraction of minerals. There are industries that are export-oriented, which can take this opportunity to get into, and grow, in non-traditional markets. It would be easy to conceive a credit, export and technology facilitation programme for these industries while continuing to keep credit tight for those sectors such as real estate which contribute to inflationary pressures. Apart from mining, one can think of light engineering, drugs and pharmaceuticals and textiles as some of the sectors which could be incentivized through monetary and fiscal concessions to grow.

Finally, this is also the time to push through the skill upgrading programmes announced in the Budget — for, if skilled labour is available, wage pressures will ease, employment will grow, and execution of projects would be speeded up.

These are suggestions that every government, notwithstanding its colour, needs to act on, and, therefore, are independent of electoral arithmetic.

S. Narayan is a former finance secretary and economic adviser to the prime minister. We welcome your comments at policytrack@livemint.com